21/01/2019

Battlestar Galactica Starship Battles

This game has not been particularly advertised as it is usual; in fact I had not know of its existence until a couple of weeks before my pal told me he got a copy. I heard people speaking highly of it, so it was a matter of necessity playing it! So say we all.


Your first thought will most probably be 'Hey, that's X-Wing, but in Galactica'. Let me tell you it is definitely not. Yes, you have a couple of fighters per side, you plan your movements in advance and you shoot. But there's much more to this game. I don't pretend to give a full review (you can download the rulebook from the Ares webpage and nothing beats reading the rules first hand), but I will try to give my impressions on the game.




Each ship has a control panel and a deck of maneuver cards. The panel control has some things you have to keep in mind. The most obvious one will be the setting on the right, going from FTL (Cylon Raiders only) down to high/medium/low speed and then to stationary and even backwards.
The round piece in the center is the rotation dial (as you can move in one direction and rotate as you fly -just like in the series, you'll see examples of that, trust me).
The kinetic energy slider down in the panel is quite a thing to bear in mind each turn; you will not be able to use maneuver cards with a total kinetic energy value higher than your kinetic energy value plus tour acceleration (or lower than your current value minus the acceleration). Sounds complicated, but it is not. It's just a way to make you aware that your spaceship has limitations and you cannot plan absurdly bold moves that would tear apart your body under the pressure of G value.
Finally, the up left part is a level slider, in order to make the game fully 3D. It's an optional rule, and we didn't use it; my pal had already played, but it was my first introductory game, so I already had some stuff to hold before making it all more complicated.

Starbuck, what do you hear? Nothing but the rain

The turn is divided in three rounds. You plan your movement, you move and then you fire. When playing the complete rules (not just the quick ones), the rounds are slightly different: first move, first fire, second move (if applicable) and second fire (if you didn't fire in the first round). To plan your moves you will use the maneuver cards:

Mostly intuitive
You can see there are differences in the movement on the same basic maneuvers, depending on your speed. There are 'overboost' cards, which allow you to draw a second card; 'difficult maneuver' cards, which don't allow another difficult maneuver nor an overboost card next turn (there are exceptions, but you get the idea).
The star card is just for bluffing. If you see your opponent drawing two cards, you will assume there will be an overboost move. Well, not necessarily ;)
The radar is a mandatory card if you want to reposition your ship after a rotation. We'll get to that eventually.

Let's see how all this fits into a game, it will be easier...

OK, so we can see only one Raider. This should be easy

My opponent decided to start the game with one Raider out of the board, making a FTL jump as his first move. No need, just for the show [Dramatic drum music here].

Contact!! (oh, please excuse the X-Wing mat. Ahem)

Swift move
When you go with the complete rules you cannot use maneuver cards with a total kinetic energy value higher than your current value plus the ship's acceleration (or lower than the your current value minus the ship's acceleration), so you have to plan carefully what you are going to do!

Next turn. I plan to do this...
...and the Raider rotates! Things are getting warm


On the other side of the table, I rotate my Viper too
Shooting phase! First thing, check your firing arc. You have a range ruler with close/medium/long range modifiers. Easy thing.

[Insert muzzled 'pew pew' effect here]
 Then roll two dice. Check the result. If it's equal or higher than your ship's attack value (usually 6, but keep the modifiers in mind; not only range, but if your target's kinetic energy is 4+, that kind of thing), you made a hit.
Neither of us got anything this time, so I'll have to explain damage rules later!
Let's see what happens with the other couple:

Graphic explanation of being rotated yet moving in a different direction. Step 1

Step 2
In the case above, the ship did not plan any movement, just let itself go by pure intertia; hence the mere straight movement.
I had rotated my Viper too, but I wanted to change route, i.e., move forward in the new direction. It takes some extra movement in your previous direction, determined by your kinetic energy and measured with a drift ruler:

After this movement, you can realign the base dial and then you are good to move normally next turn

General overview of what was happening
 I planned a cunning move with the Viper on the right. See, see:

Haha, no matter your next move, I gotcha, mwahaha

Eh? What was that?? Seriously?
So this is the real fun of the game, planning your moves ahead and trying to guess what your opponent is going to do. As you can see, I was pretty naive and these mistakes are likely to not give second chances, glups.

Meanwhile, on the left side of the table...
Nothing happened in the shooting phase. Phew. New turn.

Right side. Shoot that toaster!
Seriously? Oh, COME ON!
The other Cylon made a FTL jump. Suddenly the balance was totally broken:

My Viper on the left was useless and the one on my right was in trouble...
We can have a look at damage. When you receive a hit, you draw a random damage counter and look its value, but without revealing it to your opponent. That way, whenever you hit your enemy you can tell you did something, but you can't tell how bad you damaged the other ship.
If the token you draw has a '+' sign, then you must immediately draw a second counter (if it has a '+' too, you don't have to draw a third one). So there will be some times in which you can guess you caused some serious harm to your enemy, but without being able to tell exactly. This adds some realism and emotion to the battle, I really like that.

Damage Counters can go from 0 to 6, so you can receive a hit and get nothing or be in serious trouble. There can be special tokens (damage on the wings or whatever, with additional effects)
In the pic below you can see what happened to my Viper on my right flank. I had already received a hit (3 damage points). But now I got a 4+, so I had to draw a second token. Oh, Lords of Kobol!

A 5!! I got 9 damage points in one turn!
Vipers have 14 structure points, so things didn't look good...

So, the damaged Viper was in distress and the other one hurried to get closer.

[Drum music from the OST here] You are humming it, don't bother to deny
You see those two ships so close in the pic above? Let me explain what happened next. I thought the Raider woud finally move forward instead of letting itself go with inertia, as it had done the two previous turns.

But it didn't! The frakkin' toaster slipped with inertia another turn!!!
As I had so wrongly guessed otherwise, my move was suicide (Remember, these are done simultaneously)
No need to say, my Viper was destroyed

I made my second movement as I had chosen an overboost card
Shot and caused some damage on the Raider
Then made a difficult evasive maneuver
I slowed down my pace while the Raiders approached...
...then rotated and left myself go with inertia. I can play that game too!
Eat this, toaster!
After that I changed course and prepared myself for more maneuvers
Our job isn't to be careful, it's to shoot Cylons out of the frakkin' sky!

Oooops
Another movie moment. I rotated my Viper 180 degrees and waited for the Raider to be in shooting range...

This should work, this should work...
It did! Die, toaster, die!
Well, the Raider exploded in space
I think this gets the series vibe pretty accurately. Such moments call for desperate, bold maneuvers, and they sometimes end quite spectacularly. Anyway, as you can see in the pic above, I had hit my opponent many times, but he had drawn 0 damage not once, but twice. But he got a 6 too, and he suddenly got two damages in a row thanks to the + sign, so a ship can last for hours or be obliterated in a centon (that's an obscure reference, hehe).

So it's one to one now
It all will be decided here...

Ouch! I got a 6. I already had 10 damage points, so I was destroyed

The other Cylon was close to be destroyed too, but things went this way and I definitely lost. Mankind is a step closer to its extinction! Will what's left of the Colonies endure? We'll have to see in next chapter!

The game is enormously cool. You can see there are some quite cinematic moments, which translate in lots of fun. Tension can grow in seconds and anything can really happen. The complete rules can be learned easily and they add a lot of depth to the game, I strongly recommend them and not yet the basic core rules alone. This game took about a couple of hours, including the time for me to learn how to play; so it was great in the end.
You can see I made some serious mistakes, but also learned (from the bitter experience!) to make things work once I was familiar with what I could do. I guess the most obvious comparison is to be made with X-Wing. You can see the philosophy behind has some things in common (they both deal with fighters and dogfights in space!), but this Galactica game relies less in characters and special features (though I suspect they will eventually come as expansions if the core box sells well) and has quite more depth in maneuver and general movement terms. The fact of everything being done simultaneously and not depending on initiative or prowess is another important factor, as you won't be able to play the card of knowing that your uberpilot will do the hard work first. You have to think of your turn quite differently and then let your plans simply happen.

I really enjoyed it a lot, I'm looking forward to playing it again. So say we all!

18 comments:

  1. That looks pretty interesting Suber. Thanks for the review. I have Xwing, but it does look like this does the shop to ship combat better (with less chrome).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have X-Wing too, and though both games can look similar at first sight, I think the game dynamics are better studied here. Of course the variety of ships will be shorter in this game, but I'm interested in how will the new releases look.

      Delete
  2. Don't play (only X-wing) but looks very, very good!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It is! I enjoyed it pretty much, highly recommended.

      Delete
  3. Looks like a fun little distraction!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It is quite a delicately thought game, pretty robust I believe. I've read that it's similar to Wings of Glory, but I cannot compare. It's true that some of the dynamics (the planning, the movement cards...) remind me of Sails of Glory, but I think that the ambientation and the specific rules make the game perfect for its aim.

      Delete
  4. The minis look fantastic.
    Thanks a lot for the review!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The minis are better than one could expect from a pre-painted set. Of course any talented pro painter would make magic, in the way of those X-Wing ships you can see over the internet. But anyway, the ships are more than nice as supplied, I wouldn't touch them.
      Glad you liked the review, I hope it's of any use!

      Delete
  5. The minis look nice and it sounds like a fun game!
    Best Iain

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The game is fun indeed. I feared it would be a X-Wing clone and it certainly is not. Really, give it a try if you have the opportunity.

      Delete
  6. Being a huge fan of the old BSG and also having the entire BluRay collection of the new BSG, this game looks interesting to say the least. I must find a scale model of the old and new Vipers one of these days and paint them up. One day. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I know you are a fan, I think you may enjoy this game. Or at least the chance of painting BSG ships, of course! :D
      So say we all!

      Delete
  7. Man I love BSG! I need to get my hands on this game; those ships look awesome!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Go get it, you won't regret, take my word for it!

      Delete
  8. Thanks for the playthrough. I really like the way the rules reflect the nature of space dogfighting and your example is very clear on how they make it work. Nicely done.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks! The game deserves some love and attention, it has some pretty clever ideas and I enjoyed it a lot; I really hope the numbers make justice.

      Delete
  9. Thanks for the write up. I love the show but have been umming and ahhinh over this because of the price. You've nearly convinced me.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I know what you mean, but I think it's worth of the investment (as long as you manage to play a few times). The scary part will come when expansions arrive. We'll see what happens then.

      Delete